Reynolds vs Roberts

[blue_cheese]

I want a Lion's fan perspective. Ourbombers and GSG.com is too biased. Who do you think is better, Reynolds, or Roberts.

[Canuck_4_Life]

Roberts is more of a proven commodity.
I like Reynolds potential.

Therefore, Roberts over Reynolds.

[Rammer]

Different RB's, but Roberts has proven over time that he is a great, I have to go with that cirteria.

[Blue In BC]

Roberts no contest at the moment, but I do like what Reynolds brings to his team.

Roberts has been productive every season and relatively injury free during his career.

Let's see how Reynolds does in his CFL careeer going forward. He improved this season and I'd expect him to be evern more productive next year as Calgary improves as a team

[Lionheart]

Roberts no question. Best in the league

[Hazmat]

They are two different kind of Running Backs, Reynolds is a power running back, while Roberts is quicker and more agile. Reynolds size and strenth enables him to pound the defence, with or without the presence of a fullback, and can enable the Stampeders offence to run him from singleback.

Since I'm an advocate of power football, my choice is Reynolds.

[Rammer]

Roberts no contest at the moment, but I do like what Reynolds brings to his team.

Roberts have been productive every season and relatively injury free during his career.

Let's see how he does in his CFL careeer going forward. He improved this season and I'd expect him to be evern more productive next year as Calgary improves as a team

Please disregard this vote cast as he gives an ourbombers contribution to the mix....well sometimes. 8)

[blue_cheese]

Roberts no contest at the moment, but I do like what Reynolds brings to his team.

Roberts have been productive every season and relatively injury free during his career.

Let's see how he does in his CFL careeer going forward. He improved this season and I'd expect him to be evern more productive next year as Calgary improves as a team

Please disregard this vote cast as he gives an ourbombers contribution to the mix....well sometimes. 8)

Haha, hey I am from ourbombers too. 8)

[Blue In BC]

Roberts no contest at the moment, but I do like what Reynolds brings to his team.

Roberts have been productive every season and relatively injury free during his career.

Let's see how he does in his CFL careeer going forward. He improved this season and I'd expect him to be evern more productive next year as Calgary improves as a team

Please disregard this vote cast as he gives an ourbombers contribution to the mix....well sometimes. 8)

I speak the truth. Numbers don't lie.

[blue_cheese]

truth is right

[smithers]

I like a RB who can do more than 1 thing. Reynolds has 12 catches for 70 yards. Roberts 49 catches for 474 yards. That tells the tale of a little more versatility, since their actual rushing yardages are very similar (their average per carry being almost identical, but Roberts just gets the ball more).

One stat I'd like to know with RB's is "how many rushes for 1 yard or less"? I think Roberts gets a lot of them. He's easy to stop once you touch him, but will get a lot of yards if he gets open. Whereas a power back like Warren is more dependable on picking up that 2 or 3 yards when you need it.

[Lions_Fan_4_Life]

I pick...

ROBERTS!!!! even though any B.C. player is better :lol:

[Toppy Vann]

Roberts is more of a proven commodity.
I like Reynolds potential.

Therefore, Roberts over Reynolds.

I agree... Reynolds is all upside from here. Roberts is proven himself over the years including consistency.

[stansz]

roberts..
reynolds is too small to be a true powerback..and is nto fast enough to be a speed back

[calf_]

I want a Lion's fan perspective. Ourbombers and GSG.com is too biased. Who do you think is better, Reynolds, or Roberts.

gsg's definitely biased towards Roberts