Just where are the goalposts here?
Austin beats Buono despite time frame
Kent Gilchrist, The Province
Published: Thursday, February 28, 2008
Wally Buono didn't win the CFL Coach of the Year award again this year, which will come as no surprise to anyone close to the voting. But it should.
Since 1990, Buono has coached his teams to a first-place finish 12 times; eight when he was in Calgary coaching the Stampeders and the last four straight with the B.C. Lions.
Somehow, instead of owning the Annis Stukus trophy, awarded to the best coach in the league, Buono has won it only three times.
This for an award that is supposed to be based on regular-season performance. You can question -- even knock -- some of his game-day decisions, you can question his Grey Cup record (four wins in eight attempts), but he is several football field lengths ahead of his rivals in constructing, maintaining and finishing the regular season.
Simply take last season as an example. He lost starting quarterback Dave Dickenson and his No. 2 Buck Pierce to injuries, and his best receiver Geroy Simon was hobbled for the first two-thirds of the campaign. With Jarious Jackson at quarterback, all Buono was able to do was coax his team to a 14-win season, a franchise best.
It is interesting that the Football Reporters of Canada, a loosely-run association in which yours truly is a member but not a voter, has requested that the league change the time frame from the end of the regular season until after the Grey Cup game. It makes sense, since voters often look a little foolish when the coach of the year is announced.
Buono last won the award in 2006, the year of the Lions' last Grey Cup win. He also won in 1992 and '93. He won the Grey Cup in 1992 but lost the West final in 1993, which only shows the FRC voters probably got it right that time.
But to the layman, it would seem clear that you have to win the Grey Cup game, even though the voting is supposed to be based strictly on the regular season.
Kent Austin, who directed the Saskatchewan Roughriders to their first Grey Cup win since 1989, got 21 of the 42 first-place votes to win the Coach of the Year. Buono was runner-up with 15 votes. Michael Pinball Clemons was third and Grey Cup-game finalist Doug Berry of Winnipeg got one vote.
Everyone thought Austin was going to win and it's a deserving award and something he should have ... if it was based on the entire season, including playoffs.
The question is, how come Buono hasn't won it more often? Besides all those first-place finishes, his teams have won the Grey Cup game four times, and seven more times they've reached the West final.
Only once since he became a head coach has one of his teams missed the playoffs in 18 years. It's truly a remarkable record.
He has achieved it by understanding the individual talent on his roster. He knows when key players need to be changed.
Since the salary cap came in, it has just given him a bigger advantage. While teams are dumping big salaries and scrambling wildly to pay for some free agents at the risk of losing others, Buono has no loose ends. He dumps Mark Washington's player salary, but keeps his brain by making him a coach ... and the beat goes on.
He's so far ahead, he's negotiating contract extensions with players who still have a year left.
Ask team president Bob Ackles who his coach of the year might be.
hkgilchrist@yahoo.com© The Vancouver Province 2008